Why Some Nannies are Hired, and Others are Not

Many of my nannies and sitters lately have been confused as to why they are not getting jobs quicker, or are not getting called back after interviews. The main reason for this, is because many nannies/sitters come to Perfect Nanny Match unprepared. Many candidates come dressed for 'coffee with a friend', not 'an interview with a potential employer'.

What some candidates may or may not know, Perfect Nanny Match is the doorway to their next position. If they don't impress us, they are not going to be put in front of our families.

Some reasons nannies do not impress Perfect Nanny Match are:

  • They are not dressed business casual during interview
  • They arrive late to interview
  • Resume states their objective as having nothing to do with childcare 'Searching for a position in the field of social work'.
  • Resume is bland, has spelling errors, or correct grammar is not utilized
  • Applicants references will not respond to calls
  • Applicant is not CPR/First Aid certified, or cannot find their certificates
  • Applicant does not have formal childcare training, or college courses
  • Applicant does not have a portfolio

Some of the above mentioned reasons are quite easy to fix:

  • Have several different resumes, one for each type of job you are applying for
  • Have a third party take a look at your resume for errors (the library generally has free resume classes/mentors)
  • Let your references know that someone will be calling, and possibly give them the name/number of the person calling so they are prepared
  • Take a CPR/First Aid class, and make sure you make copies of your certificate

But the biggest subject I would like to discuss is your portfolio. For my beginning nannies and sitters, you might not even know what a portfolio is. I will try and explain the best way I can. I can assure you that if you have a portfolio, and you bring it to your interview with Perfect Nanny Match, you will get moved to the top of the list, and will from that point on be one of my 'better candidates'.

You will not only impress Perfect Nanny Match, but the family you interview will also be blown away with how detailed, informative and professional you are because of your portfolio. Many nannies simply have all these items in a binder, some of them are in scrapbook form, some are very tidy and neat, others are more creative. Whichever way you choose to present your portfolio, make sure it has some, if not all of these components:

  • Headshot of just yourself
  • Photos of you 'at work' with your charges
  • Your professional nanny resume
  • Personal Narrative (describing you as a person, interests, values)
  • Work History
  • Letters of recommendation
  • Professional Development completed
  • Awards Received/Certificates
  • A detail sheet describing what a perfect nanny job looks like to you
  • Art project ideas
  • Activity ideas for different age groups

Not every nanny or sitter will have these items, but at least having a binder with most of these items will keep everything in one place, and will impress whoever it's presented to. These tips are not mentioned to worry, or scare nannies or sitters who have not yet been placed with a family, but are presented to give some insight as to why this may be happening. Feel free to comment and share your opinion or ideas!


Lena Santacaterina (Owner of Perfect Nanny Match)

Spring Break Activities

Spring break is coming! As you travel the web in search of new and exciting ideas to have fun with your children you’ll occasionally come across a gem! We happened to do just that when we found Activity Mom today. Maybe you’re...

Writing a Thank You Card

Recently, one of my clients sent me an excited email because one of my nanny candidates sent them a thank you card after her interview. They were extremely impressed by the gesture! They told me that out of at least 10+ candidates that they had...

Adorable Halloween Costumes for the Whole Family

Halloween is Coming! Halloween is a little over a month away. Where is the time going!? That means that families in the Metro Detroit area are going to be scurrying to the store (or to be safe, online) to find their family a proper Halloween...

Cheap Way to Make Laundry Detergent!

Even if you don't use cloth diapers in your house, this recipe from my good friend Brandi Hohner will work for your family! Check out her price breakdown at the end, it's a staggering difference from store-bought detergents. Thanks Brandi...

Nannies Know How to Have Fun!

Ever wonder what nannies do when they aren't wiping snot off of a child's nose? Well, we like to have fun. We like to go out, we like to tell jokes, we like to have a glass (or two) of wine, and we like to share our stories. Take a look at...

Fun Halloween Recipes for Children!

Over the weekend I hosted a kid friendly Halloween party. I spent Friday preparing a few cute Halloween activities, and recipes for everyone to enjoy. I have added the recipes so you can do them with your family and children. I tried to take the...

24 Qualities of a Great Nanny

Thank you to Morningside Nannies who wrote this fabulous article. See original article here: Qualities of a GREAT Nanny: 1. A great nanny genuinely loves the company of children. Nannies...

Time Outs: What Do You Think?

All my life I was out in time outs. I was told to stand in the corner, go to your room and 'think about what you did' and told to 'sit quietly, and tell me in 5 minutes what you did wrong'. This was how I grew up, so I hardly know...

Peanut Butter Caterpillar

Check out this fun, easy way to make a caterpillar out of a banana, and some peanut butter! Add celery/carrots to make it cute! Ingredients 1 banana 2 Tbsp....

If You Give a Nanny a Naptime...

This poem was written by a few nanny friends of mine. Based off the book 'If You Give a Mouse a Cookie" If you give a nanny a naptime… She’ll finally get to go to the bathroom in peace. While she’s washing her...

Spring Break Ideas for Kids!

Spring break is fast approaching for many families. That means that unless you are going on vacation, you will have some very bored kiddos here in Michigan! I have compiled a list of some really fun, inexpensive (and some for FREE) activities to do...

When Your Job Description Keeps Growing

Job creep, when your employer keeps adding tasks to your job description, is one of the biggest challenges you can face as a nanny. You want to help, you want to do a great job, you want to pitch in but you also don’t want to feel taken...

11 Step Program for Those Thinking of Having Kids

11 Step Program for those thinking of Having Kids: (from a good friend...had to share!) Lesson 1 1. Go to the grocery store. 2. Arrange to have your salary paid directly to their head office. 3. Go home. 4. Pick up the paper. 5....

Two Ingredient Slime!

I love ideas for easy crafts, don't you? This idea takes only two main ingredients (and food coloring if you want to make it pretty) There are a few ways to make slime, however I found this recipe works best ~ 1 1/2 cups of CLEAR glue...

PNM Gets Featured!

Perfect Nanny Match was featured in the Farmington Patch website this morning! They feature one small business every week and I happened to be the chosen one this week. Here's the article! Thanks Patch for featuring Perfect Nanny...

Making Rules, and Breaking Rules

This article is excerpted from “The Mister Rogers Parenting Book” the last book Fred Rogers worked on before his death in 2003. Making Rules: Choose a few rules that matter most. Children are more likely to know what’s...

'Tis the Season – for Some Quiet

'Tis the Season – for Some Quiet By Hedda Sharapan A colleague of mine told me she’s already feeling the stressful effects of the holiday season in her child care.  There seems to be more anxiety, tension, irritability and...
Page: 123 - All